Shelter Island
New York
Shelter Island Gas Prices - Find the Lowest Gas Prices in Shelter Island, NY
Search for the lowest gasoline prices in Shelter Island, NY. Find local Shelter Island gas prices and Shelter Island gas stations with the best prices to fill up at the pump today
National and New York Gas Price Averages
| National Avg. | NY Reg. Avg. | NY Plus Avg. | NY Prem. Avg. | NY Diesel Avg. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
$3.180
05/03/2025
|
$3.105
05/03/2025
|
$3.617
05/03/2025
|
$4.003
05/03/2025
|
$3.909
05/03/2025
|
Today's lowest gas prices in New York and around Shelter Island
| Station | Regular | Plus | Premium | Diesel |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Ron's Smoke Shop 5001 NY-417, Allegany, NY |
$2.32
05/03/2025
|
05/03/2025
|
05/03/2025
|
05/03/2025
|
WW Vandalia Gas Mart 5017 NY-417, Allegany, NY |
$2.33
05/03/2025
|
05/03/2025
|
05/03/2025
|
05/03/2025
|
COVID-19 Resources
Add an Event
See All Events
Local Events
Kentucky Derby at The Club House
Saturday, May 3, 2025 from 4:00pm to 8:00pm
East Hampton, NY
More info »
Architecture Of The Overflow: A Live Performance by Emily Johnson
Sunday, May 4, 2025 from 3:00pm to 4:30pm
Sag Harbor, NY
More info »
See All Events
In and Around Shelter Island, NY