9 Best Nature Centers in New York!

Featuring

Mashomack Preserve, Shelter Island, NY

Covering a large portion of Shelter Island, Mashomack contains some of the best wildlife there is to be seen on Long Island. The island has an extremely large population of wild ospreys, who come… Read More

9 Best Lunch Spots in New York!

Featuring

Candy Kitchen, Bridgehampton, NY

This Hamptons landmark diner is a must-visit. Enjoy a burger and a milkshake for lunch as you take in old-fashioned décor hasn’t changed in decades.

Read More

9 Best Wineries and Vineyards in New York!

Featuring

Raphael Winery, Peconic, NY

Billing itself as an “old-world vineyard,” Raphael Winery’s space has a beautiful, distinctly European feel to it. They offer tours of the vineyard for $65 and tastings on the… Read More

The 10 Best Seafood Restaurants in New York!

Featuring

Bostwick’s Chowder House, East Hampton, NY

This casual seafood spot has been a Hamptons hotspot for years. Expect an array of fresh-off-the-boat seafood like halibut, swordfish, and tuna, as well as comfort food classics like fried clams and… Read More

8 Best Mom and Pop Restaurants in New York!

Featuring

Candy Kitchen, Bridgehampton, NY

This iconic diner is a must-stop in the Hamptons, and it’s been around for decades. Fans of this mom and pop restaurant love it for its adorable interior, traditional diner fare, and homemade… Read More

10 Best Breakfast Spots in New York!

Featuring

Love Lane Kitchen, Mattituck, NY

This bright café serves breakfast seven days a week on Long Island’s north fork, which also happens to be its wine country. Stop in after a wine tasting for some fresh coffee, pancakes,… Read More

6 Best Places for a Bloody Mary in New York!

Featuring

Nick & Toni’s, East Hampton, NY

This restaurant’s Bloody Board is available on Sundays until Memorial Day, when brunch service is suspended for the summer season. Pick and choose to make a unique Bloody Mary. Choice of vodka,… Read More

The 9 Best Luxury Car Dealerships in New York!

Featuring

Porsche of Southampton, Southampton, NY

Certified sales professionals and highly-trained technicians contribute to this Hamptons Porsche dealer’s stellar reputation. Find all of the latest Porsche models at this awesome dealership. … Read More

9 Best Brunch Spots in New York!

Featuring

Love Lane Kitchen, Mattituck, NY

With a breakfast served every day of the week until 2 p.m., you know this brunch place is dedicated to the craft. The charming, upscale kitchen boasts an extensive egg menu as well as griddle… Read More

The 15 Best Camping Spots in New York!

Featuring

Hither Hills State Park, Montauk, NY

With 168 camping spots on the ocean, miles of hiking and horseback riding trails, two miles of sandy beach, and a nature preserve Hither Hills State Park in Montauk offers the perfect blend of… Read More

Event

Leslie Mendelson

Event

Title Wave: The New Works Festival

Event

Faster Things - Allman Brothers Tribute

Event

Take 3

Add an Event

Events Around Shelter Island

Sag Harbor Farmers Market

Saturday, May 31, 2025 from 9:00am to 1:00pm

Sag Harbor, NY

More info »

Live Music by 12X

Saturday, May 31, 2025 from 1:30pm to 5:30pm

Greenport, NY

More info »

Performance - Bob and Jean: A Love Story

Saturday, May 31, 2025 at 8:00pm

Sag Harbor, NY

More info »

Performance - Bob and Jean: A Love Story

Sunday, Jun 1, 2025 at 7:00pm

Sag Harbor, NY

More info »

Performance - Bob and Jean: A Love Story

Tuesday, Jun 3, 2025 at 7:00pm

Sag Harbor, NY

More info »

See All Events

Add Your News

Local News Feed

Volunteer New York News: Local Volunteer Opportunities for May 29, 2025

From: Volunteer New York

Local volunteer opportunities as of May 29, 2025 Juneteenth Festival Is Here! PLUS: Girls on t...

Governor Hochul Announces Opening of 'Waterway of Change' at Canalside in Buffalo

From: New York Governor Kathy Hochul

Interactive, Multimedia Exhibits at the Longshed Building Will Welcome Visitors During 2025 Erie ...

Governor Hochul Announces 31 Transformational Projects in the Finger Lakes as Part of Downtown Revitalization Initiative and NY Forward Programs

From: New York Governor Kathy Hochul

Projects Announced in Waterloo, Webster and Macedon Pro-Housing Communities Designation Ties I...

Governor Hochul Announces 28 Transformational Projects in the Hudson Valley as Part of Downtown Revitalization Initiative and NY Forward Programs

From: New York Governor Kathy Hochul

Projects Announced in White Plains, Highland Falls and Montgomery Project Renderings Available...

Money in Your Pockets: Governor Hochul Signs Legislation to Protect Energy Consumers and Lower Energy Costs

From: New York Governor Kathy Hochul

Legislation S.7230/A.6762 Puts Money Back Into New Yorkers’ Pockets and Protects Consumers ...

NEW REAL ESTATE
Listings

Classifieds & Deals

RESTAURANTS

American Chinese Italian Breakfast & Diners Pizza View All Restaurants

Add an Organization

Organizations around Shelter Island

Saint Mary's Saint Nicolas Fair

More info »

Saint Mary's Fall Craft And Vendor Fair

More info »

Shelter Island Public Library Holiday Craft Fair

More info »

Shelter Island High School

More info »

Shelter Island Craft Brewery

More info »

See All Organizations

Shelter Island Town Facts

Shelter Island, New York. Population for Shelter Island from the last gathering is 1234. You can view Shelter Island venues that host many Shelter Island NY events every year.

You can find a ton of properties for sale if you search the Shelter Island page on Zillow. Currently Shelter Island has an average listing price for homes for sale on the market of $631,372. More real estate facts about Shelter Island: The number of properties currently for sale in Shelter Island is 78. The median homes for sale listing price is $409,000. This is broken down with the number of three bedroom houses in Shelter Island consisting of 27 with an average listing price for these house of $451,944. Out of the 28 houses that are four bedroom the average listing price for Shelter Island is $638,782. Interest rates for Shelter Island are at historic lows as well.

Shelter Island New York has a latitude of 41.05659866333 and a longitude of -72.324996948242. View the full profile

In and Around Shelter Island, NY

Apple Picking Corn Mazes Pumpkin Picking Halloween Events Restaurants Movie Times Car Deals and Guide Real Estate Jobs Classifieds Gas Prices Museums Coffee Spots Parks

Community Life

School Closings
View our updated school closings list.

Local Schools
Find education near you.

Local Groups
View all the organizations in your community.

Businesses
VFind popular businesses near you.

Jobs
Looking to work locally? Try these listings we found.

COVID-19 Resources

Coronavirus Resource Guide Preppers Guide

Shelter Island Tool Kit

NON-PROFIT
BUSINESS

Events Around Shelter Island

Local News Feed

RESTAURANTS

Organizations around Shelter Island

Shelter Island Town Facts

School Closings View our updated school closings list.

Local Schools Find education near you.

Local Groups View all the organizations in your community.

Businesses VFind popular businesses near you.

Jobs Looking to work locally? Try these listings we found.

COVID-19 Resources

List Your Organization

Post An Event

Submit A News Release

Free: See How You're Listed

Improve Your Listing

New Businesses

20 million peoplerely on AmericanTowns each year to find & share local information.

School Closings
View our updated school closings list.

Local Schools
Find education near you.

Local Groups
View all the organizations in your community.

Businesses
VFind popular businesses near you.

Jobs
Looking to work locally? Try these listings we found.

20 million people
rely on AmericanTowns each year to find & share local information.